Businessman Rob Evans at the Gqeberha High Court.
Businessman Rob Evans at the Gqeberha High Court. Photo: Shanti Jafta

Rob Evans trial: Court hears frantic calls for help


GQEBERHA – The fifth day of the Rob Evans murder trial took place yesterday, 10 November, at the Gqeberha High Court, where the court heard testimonies from three witnesses: Michael McAfee, Christo Joubert and Paul Middleton, owner of Calibre Security in St Francis Bay.

Frantic calls for help played in court

In today’s proceedings, the court heard a voice recording of the accused making a call to his security company, Calibre Security, at 01:32, requesting urgent assistance at his Oyster Bay holiday home. The court also heard a voice recording of the accused making another phone call at 01:36 to the security company, saying that help had not yet arrived.

Evans made the first call for help almost two hours after he allegedly took photos of the deceased’s seemingly lifeless body, as was reported by the Express previously.

Speaking on the witness stand, Middleton explained to the court that they don’t normally keep the recordings. He said the company keeps the recordings of calls made to the security company for approximately three months before deleting them, unless asked to do otherwise by authorities, which was the case in this instance.

In the voice recording, Evans’ words were slightly slurred, making it slightly difficult for the phone operator to hear him properly. In the video, he was panicking, requesting urgent assistance.

During cross-examination, defence attorney Paul Roelofse asked whether complaints are recorded when they are made via the switchboard, to which Middleton said no. “However, they are logged after every shift,” he confirmed. The defence had no further questions for Middleton.

Neighbour heard heated argument

Another witness, Christo Joubert, told the court that he also has a holiday home next door to Evans and was at the home during the period of the incident.

Joubert added that they were on a fishing trip during the day and came home around 20:00 to the sounds of arguing, allegedly between Evans and van Rensburg. “The house was lit when we passed and when we got home, I heard a heated argument,” he said, adding that he predominantly heard a woman’s voice. He added that he could not make out what the argument was about.

Joubert also told the court that he could hear the argument as he and his family were offloading the fishing equipment from their vehicle. He added that he stepped out onto his deck around 23:00 to smoke a cigarette and saw Evans sitting on his stoop making phone calls.

Roelofse asked whether Joubert could see Evans’ house from the deck, and he confirmed that he could only see the stoop from that angle. He confirmed that from the angle he was positioned in, he could only see the front main entrance as well as the stoop, but could not see into the sliding door where van Rensburg was lying.

Joubert was also asked if he heard the argument, which he said he didn’t, as well as whether he saw any fighting or glass breaking, and he said no. He also confirmed that he could not see anyone else on the property. He also told the court that he had never seen Evans angry or violent with anyone.

Long-time friend testifies

Another witness, McAfee, a friend of Evans for about 15 years, also testified in court before they shared a moment. During a short adjournment, McAfee walked up to Evans to wish him luck, and Evans jokingly said, “I can’t speak to a witness,” before shaking hands.

McAfee told the court his account of the events of the day. He went to Oyster Bay to have drinks with his friend, Keith Belling, who was on the witness stand previously, but could not remember where Belling lived. He passed Evans’ holiday home at approximately 15:00 and found him and van Rensburg unpacking their luggage. He asked Evans for directions to Belling’s home, and Evans invited him in for a drink before showing him where Belling lived.

McAfee added that Vanessa left Belling’s residence, where they were all gathered, at around 19:30. He stated that there was no animosity between Evans and van Rensburg. He explained that he does not remember when Evans left; however, he does remember telling him that van Rensburg had left before going back to mingle with guests. Evans left shortly after.

When Belling took McAfee to Evans’ home, where his car was parked, he found Evans sitting on the stoop with a coolerbox and a glass in hand, adding that the entrance door was closed. When he asked Evans why he was sitting outside, he said, “I can’t go in. Come help me.” That’s when they tried to jimmy open the door.

McAfee added that Evans was intoxicated but was able to move around. “He didn’t stumble or anything,” he said. He also stated that he did not stay long, alleging that he needed to go home.

During cross-examination, it came to light that Evans allegedly did not remember the encounter with McAfee. He doesn’t dispute that it happened, but just doesn’t remember. Additionally, he added that in the time he has known Evans, he has not seen him treat van Rensburg badly before.

The matter was stood down for the day until today, 11 November. Evans remains in custody.

ALSO READ: Differing photos of Vanessa’s body raise questions

NovaNews WhatsApp channel QR code

You need to be Logged In to leave a comment.

Gift this article