Coalition talks between ActionSA and DA turn messy

A collage image of Herman Mashaba and Helen Zille.
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba and the DA’s Helen Zille face tensions over coalition negotiations in Gauteng metros.

Coalition talks between ActionSA and DA turn messy

A collage image of Herman Mashaba and Helen Zille.
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba and the DA’s Helen Zille face tensions over coalition negotiations in Gauteng metros.

JOHANNESBURG – A coalition between the DA and ActionSA to govern Gauteng’s metros together looks unlikely due to ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba’s “excessive” demands.

According to Roland Henwood, Mashaba’s conditions reduce the chances of an agreement between the two parties.

The DA and ActionSA have enough seats together to govern in Tshwane. They also secured a combined 51.04% of support in Johannesburg and 49.18% in Ekurhuleni. Where they do not have an outright seat majority together, a third party could possibly get involved.

Mashaba’s demands cause friction

TimesLIVE reports that, in a letter to DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis, Mashaba proposed that both he and Helen Zille, the DA’s mayoral candidate in Johannesburg, withdraw from the mayoral race. The DA must then appoint a replacement for Zille whom ActionSA will support. In exchange, ActionSA wants the deputy mayor position in Johannesburg.

Mashaba also reportedly asks that Cilliers Brink, the DA’s mayoral candidate in Tshwane, withdraw and that the DA supports ActionSA’s candidate, Dr Nasiphi Moya. Moya currently serves as Tshwane’s mayor. Brink declined to comment.

Michael Beaumont, ActionSA chairperson, confirmed the letter exists but would not elaborate on its contents.

Support levels favour DA

According to Henwood, the DA and ActionSA can govern in Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni with the VF Plus’s help. However, Mashaba’s demands complicate this possibility, he believes.

“Such a coalition will not happen easily because of Mashaba’s demands. You cannot insist that the DA withdraws its most important mayor (Zille) that has driven significant success for the party in Johannesburg.”

Henwood says Mashaba’s demands must weigh against the parties’ respective support levels. According to him, ActionSA roughly doubled its national support to about 5%, with 16.27% of support in Johannesburg and 22.07% in Tshwane. The DA received significantly more support.

He believes Mashaba cannot make such demands publicly before negotiations have properly begun.

Past mistrust complicates talks

According to Henwood, mistrust exists between the parties because of coalition agreements that broke down in the past at local government level.

“When it comes to values and policy, ActionSA and the DA stand closer to each other. However, when it comes to stable government and concluding a comprehensive agreement, the ANC is the better option for the DA,” Henwood says.

The DA and ANC handle their coalition negotiations at national level. The DA’s federal executive committee (FedEx) takes part in the negotiations. In the ANC-camp, secretary-general Fikile Mbalula leads the negotiations together with ministers Parks Tau, Enoch Godongwana and Gwede Mantashe.

According to Henwood, the negotiations can also affect the DA and ANC’s relationship within the government of national unity.

You need to be Logged In to leave a comment.

Gift this article