ActionSA president Herman Mashaba has issued a strong rebuke to political commentators and rival parties attempting to influence the organisation’s coalition negotiations, declaring that the party’s independence “is not up for negotiation”.
In a strongly-worded statement released over the weekend, Mashaba accused critics of trying to “bully, undermine and dictate” to ActionSA following the 4 November municipal elections, which left several major metros including Johannesburg and Tshwane without clear majorities.
“Let me make this absolutely clear: ActionSA is an independent political party. We are not an extension of the DA, the ANC, the EFF or any other political organisation,” Mashaba said.
The statement comes as coalition negotiations continue in key metros, with ActionSA holding potential kingmaker positions in several municipalities.
Historical tensions with DA resurface
Mashaba revisited his October 2019 resignation from the Democratic Alliance and his position as Johannesburg mayor, following Helen Zille’s election as the party’s Federal Council chairperson. He questioned why critics remained silent when he walked away from the DA over fundamental disagreements about inequality and party direction.
“Where were these voices when the DA turned its back on me in 2019?” he asked.
The ActionSA leader also detailed the collapse of the Johannesburg coalition in January 2023, when mayor Mpho Phalatse was removed through a motion of no confidence. Mashaba blamed the DA’s Federal Executive for rejecting a negotiated agreement with the Patriotic Alliance that could have saved the coalition.
He further criticised the DA for entering discussions with the ANC following the 2024 national elections and joining the Government of National Unity, despite the Multiparty Charter’s commitment to avoid separate coalition talks with the ANC.
Tshwane coalition yields results
Mashaba pointed to Tshwane as evidence that cross-party coalitions can deliver results. ActionSA’s Dr Nasiphi Moya was elected executive mayor in October 2024 through a coalition that included the ANC and EFF.
Under Moya’s leadership, the city presented its first fully funded budget in three years and reduced its Eskom debt by about R1 billion in its first 175 days, Mashaba said.
Parliament’s Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs Portfolio Committee welcomed the city’s financial turnaround in April 2025.
Double standards in coalition politics
The ActionSA president challenged what he described as a double standard, where political pragmatism is accepted when exercised by the DA but criticised when ActionSA makes independent decisions.
“Why must ActionSA be held to standards that other political parties are apparently free to disregard?” he asked.
Mashaba said coalition decisions must be assessed against their ability to deliver services and improve lives, rather than satisfying “political egos or ideological preferences”.
He also challenged the notion that any party has solved poverty and inequality, pointing to Cape Town’s own 2024/25 Integrated Annual Report which records that 18.2% of the city’s population lives below the poverty line, amounting to about 231 030 indigent households.
“We cannot pretend that a particular political party has all the answers whilst millions of people remain trapped in circumstances that deny them economic freedom and dignity,” he said.
‘I’m demanding respect’
Mashaba concluded with a direct warning to those attempting to influence ActionSA’s coalition choices.
“To those who believe that they can bully ActionSA into submission, I have a message: you have misunderstood both this organisation and the person leading it,” he said.
“I’m not asking for respect. I’m demanding it. Not because I am Herman Mashaba… but because I lead a legitimate political organisation with a democratic mandate, a constituency and a responsibility to millions of South Africans.”
The party will determine its own political future based on the interests of voters, particularly those “left behind by decades of political failure”, Mashaba said.
ALSO READ: Coalition talks between ActionSA and DA turn messy





