The arrest of Mitchells Plain Member of Parliament Fadiel Adams last week has drawn a sharp and divided response from politicians, activists and members of the public.

The founder of the National Coloured Congress (NCC) was taken into custody on Wednesday, 5 May, on charges of fraud and defeating or obstructing the ends of justice.

The arrest

Before his arrest the South African Police Service (SAPS) publicly called on Adams to hand himself over. Arrangements had been made with his attorney for him to report to the Cape Town Central Police Station on Monday 4 May 2026, but he did not do so. He also failed to appear before a KwaZulu-Natal court on the same day.

Officers from the police’s Political Killings Task Team (PKTT) subsequently raided his former home in Westridge before tracking him down at a separate undisclosed address. Adams and the NCC recorded and shared footage of the arrest online.

According to the police the charges relate to allegations that Adams interfered with the investigation into the murder of ANC Youth League leader Sindiso Magaqa. They said Adams had made contact with the convicted hitman in the Magaqa case at a critical stage of their investigation. A J50 warrant of arrest had been issued for him.

Public reaction

The arrest, and the manner in which it was carried out, prompted strong responses online.

Grant Pascoe, former subcouncil chair for Mitchells Plain, urged the public not to focus solely on who was arrested, but on how the arrest was handled.

“Fadiel Adams does not need to be a hero for this argument to matter,” he wrote. “The law must be strong enough to hold him accountable without cutting corners. If the state cannot follow proper procedure in a case such as this, where there is public attention and legal scrutiny, then it raises serious concern about how it behaves in cases that attract no attention at all.”

Pascoe pointed to reports of a pre-dawn raid by masked officers, entry into a home no longer linked to Adams, and claims that firearms were pointed at people in the house, including a child. He said a warrant was allegedly not shown when one was requested.

“A warrant is not a small detail,” he wrote. “It is a basic legal protection. It confirms that a court has authorised the police to enter a private space. If a warrant exists, it must be shown.”

Pascoe questioned what such conduct meant for ordinary people who have no public profile, media attention or legal support. “When something goes wrong in an ordinary home, there are no cameras and no public scrutiny. There is often no legal team ready to respond. That is where the real risk lies.”

Commentator Moeshfieka Botha raised concerns about what she described as an unequal application of the law.

“I have questions on Fadiel Adams’s actions. I 100% support the law taking its course. But I also really want what is good for the goose to be good for the gander.”

Botha questioned why the same urgency was not applied to those she said had stolen billions of rands, affecting health care, education, food security and the daily lives of ordinary South Africans. She added that she was not a member of or affiliated to the NCC in any way.

Mitchells Plain attorney Fazloodien Abrahams described the arrest as an attempt to silence someone who had spoken out against corruption and stood up for neglected communities. He called for the law to apply equally to all and said the coloured community could see through what he termed hypocrisy and betrayal by those in power.

The NCC’s response

The NCC held a press conference at its Westridge constituency office on Sunday, 10 May 2026, when it released a statement defending Adams and questioning the legality of the arrest.

The party said Adams was arrested at his parliamentary home in Pelican Park and argued that the PKTT had no authority to enter the parliamentary precinct without the permission of the Speaker of Parliament. The NCC said it would be writing to the Speaker to find out whether such permission had been given or sought.

The party also challenged the scale of the operation. It noted that more than 10 PKTT officers had been deployed in the Western Cape for over a week, that Adams was transported to KwaZulu-Natal under armed guard and 10 prosecutors had appeared in court for what the NCC described as a schedule 1 offence.

“We have not witnessed this level of attention for a schedule 1 offence in our democratic existence,” the party said.

The NCC said the charges stemmed from Adams’ visit to Westville Prison, where he met a convicted murderer and obtained a statement that he then submitted to the Police Portfolio Committee (PPC) in February 2025. The party argued that such visits are legally permitted under the Correctional Services Act and parliamentary standing rules, and Adams was carrying out his constitutional oversight duty as an MP.

The NCC cited Section 58 of the Constitution, which it said protects members of Parliament from civil or criminal proceedings for anything submitted to Parliament or its committees. It also cited Section 55(2), which requires the National Assembly to maintain oversight of the executive, including the police.

The party noted that PPC chairperson Ian Cameron of the Democratic Alliance had acknowledged that Adams carried out the prison visit without first obtaining his approval, but argued that this did not make the visit unlawful, and that any such concern should have been raised more than a year earlier as a parliamentary matter rather than a criminal one.

The NCC also raised procedural concerns about the court appearance. It said the investigating officer was absent from court on 9 May 2026, the day Adams appeared before a magistrate, despite having had two days’ notice of his arrival. The party further noted that the warrant of arrest, issued on 30 April 2026, included an affidavit in which investigators stated they were unsure whether Adams was still a serving MP, even though the head of the PKTT had attended a meeting of the Portfolio Committee on Police with Adams the previous day, on 29 April 2026.

“We in no way seek special treatment in terms of the law for Hon. Adams,” the NCC said, “but request reasonableness, justice and fairness.”

The party said it would continue to expose corruption and would not be deterred by what it described as threats from the PKTT or any other political party or individual.

READ ALSO: National Coloured Congress leader Fadiel Adams remains in custody