Imagine an alternate timeline where the Springboks’ attacking evolution never happened. Where the double world champions stuck to their conservative playbook and Felipe Contepomi’s Argentina boasted one of rugby’s sharpest tactical minds instead. That nightmare scenario for South African rugby fans was closer to reality than anyone realised, and it all came down to one phone call.
Also read: Why the Stormers are not getting carried away after two big wins
Tony Brown, the mastermind behind the Springboks’ increasingly expansive game since joining as attack coach in 2024, has revealed he was on the verge of heading to Buenos Aires before Rassie Erasmus finally sealed the deal. Speaking on the Plumtree Uncut Podcast this week, hosted by former Sharks coach and fellow New Zealander John Plumtree, Brown laid bare just how close South Africa came to missing out on his services entirely.
Also read: Solontsi takes bok women captaincy as Latsha injury rocks camp
The revelation offers a fascinating glimpse into how a few months of radio silence nearly sent one of the game’s brightest coaching minds to the Pampas instead of the Highveld.
The waiting game
Brown had wrapped up his stint with Japan following the 2023 Rugby World Cup, working alongside head coach Jamie Joseph. But there’d been a tantalising phone call from Erasmus about joining the back-to-back world champions.
Then… nothing.
“Rassie had already rung me about joining South Africa and then it sort of got to Christmas time, and I didn’t have a contract,” Brown explained. “I didn’t hear from him for a couple of months, so I thought, ‘Oh, maybe that opportunity’s gone’.”
Enter Argentina
Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does international rugby. Whilst Brown waited for word from South Africa, Argentina’s newly appointed head coach Felipe Contepomi made his move. The former Ireland and Leinster assistant saw an opportunity and pounced, approaching Brown about joining Los Pumas’ coaching ticket.
It was a compelling proposition. Argentina are an emerging force in world rugby, boasting passionate support and a talented playing pool. Under Contepomi’s leadership, with Brown orchestrating the attack, they could have become genuine threats to the southern hemisphere’s traditional powerhouses.
“I was sort of waiting for Rassie to give me another call,” Brown said.
The gamble paid off. Erasmus eventually rang back with the offer Brown had been hoping for.
“He said, ‘Right, we’re keen to sign you if you want to sign,’ and I just said, ‘Yes, I’ll sign straight away’.”
No regrets
Brown’s decision to back himself and wait for the Springbok call has been vindicated comprehensively. Since joining the setup, he’s been instrumental in adding layers to South Africa’s traditionally forward-dominated game plan, helping develop an attack that can unpick defences as effectively as the Bomb Squad can batter them.
“I’m glad I did,” Brown reflected. “[It’s] an amazing team to coach, [and] obviously a great country to spend a lot of time in. It’s a rugby country, which, when I was a player and when you toured here, it was special. Now I’m coaching here, it’s special as well.”
That authenticity shines through. Brown isn’t just punching the clock in Pretoria; he’s genuinely invested in South African rugby’s culture and heritage.
“South Africa’s always the toughest place to play rugby and win,” Brown observed. “When I was playing for the Highlanders or the All Blacks, there’s always great rugby players here. I think now, with how Rassie’s developed this rugby team, it’s exceptional. And then all the young guys coming through in the Under-20s, and how South Africa have got that right, like, they’re winning all those Under-20s tournaments now, so they’ve got everything right in South Africa at the moment.”.
Brown is contracted with the Springboks until after the 2027 Rugby World Cup in Australia, where South Africa will attempt an unprecedented third consecutive title. After that, he’s set to join the All Blacks, a homecoming that’ll see him bring everything he’s learned in the southern hemisphere’s two most successful rugby nations back to New Zealand.
But that’s tomorrow’s concern. Right now, Brown’s focused on refining the Springbok attack, developing the next generation of playmakers, and ensuring South Africa’s dominance continues.
