A new University of the Western Cape (UWC) study is calling for a balanced approach to male circumcision in South Africa — one that protects the health of young men without stripping away the cultural traditions that give the practice its meaning.

Boyhood to manhood

The review, published in the African Journal of Religion, Philosophy and Culture, looked at the experiences of young men between the ages of 18 and 25 in the Bizana district of the Eastern Cape. For many South African communities, Traditional Male Circumcision (TMC) is far more than a ritual. It marks the transition from boyhood to manhood, shapes identity and passes on important values.

But deaths and serious injuries among initiates have raised growing concerns about its safety. Medical Male Circumcision (MMC) offers important health benefits and reduces many of the risks linked to traditional practices. However, researchers found that communities where TMC is deeply rooted are reluctant to embrace MMC because they believe it does not carry the same cultural meaning — resulting in low uptake.

Lead researcher and UWC lecturer Lindani Sthembele Maphumulo, together with co-author Saziso Cromwell Qwaka, explored the tensions between the two approaches using a framework that places African worldviews, cultural authority and indigenous knowledge at the centre of the discussion. The researchers found that MMC campaigns have largely been shaped by Western medical thinking focused on disease prevention. As a result, traditional circumcision tends to be viewed mainly as a health risk, rather than the important cultural institution it is.

Ownership

TMC, the study found, carries social, spiritual and moral meaning that cannot be fully understood outside of its cultural context. Young men who underwent traditional circumcision reported that the teachings received during ceremonies made them feel more mature, responsible and less likely to be abusive. MMC, by contrast, was linked to stigma and shame among Xhosa initiates in the Eastern Cape, and was seen as a mark of immaturity and embarrassment. The researchers are calling for an approach that allows traditional and medical circumcision to co-exist, while giving African communities ownership over their own practices.

They argue that stronger collaboration between traditional leaders, healthcare professionals and government is essential to improve safety without compromising cultural integrity. “The future challenge involves bringing these two approaches together to ensure cultural preservation without compromising public health and safety standards. Government intervention, community education and cross-cultural dialogue will be key,” the researchers noted.

ALSO READ: UWC positions itself on the forefront of digital transformation