Parliament is advancing controversial tobacco legislation that would fundamentally reshape how cigarettes are sold in the country, but law enforcement agencies and tax authorities are raising red flags about unintended consequences that could benefit criminal enterprises.
The Control of Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Bill, currently undergoing its final round of public consultations, proposes several dramatic changes to tobacco regulation. The legislation would mandate plain packaging requiring all tobacco products to use standardised, unbranded packaging, while expanding smoking bans to all indoor public spaces and certain outdoor areas. The bill also introduces stricter sales restrictions to minors, prohibits advertising and promotion, and establishes new regulations for electronic delivery systems like vapes.
While some measures have gained stakeholder support, the plain packaging requirement has emerged as the most contentious provision, drawing criticism from an unexpected source: the country’s own enforcement agencies.
The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has issued warnings about the plain packaging proposal, arguing it could inadvertently supercharge the country’s already massive illegal cigarette trade. SARS officials told parliament during consultation hearings that if all packaging looks the same, then the illicit market, which makes up as much as 75% of the entire industry, could find it far easier to operate.
The revenue service’s concerns centre on a troubling reality: when legitimate products look identical to illegal ones, criminals can more easily blend their contraband into the legal market. Instead of plain packaging, SARS has proposed large, visible health warnings that would serve public health goals while allowing easier identification of legally regulated products.
If all packaging looks the same, then the illicit market, which makes up as much as 75% of the entire industry, could find it far easier to operate.
South Africa’s concerns aren’t theoretical. The country experienced a real-world case study in tobacco prohibition during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, when tobacco sales were completely banned. The results were devastating for legitimate businesses and a boon for criminals, with tax revenue plummeting from R14 billion in 2019 to just R9 billion in 2021. During this period, cigarette consumption actually increased by approximately 1.6 billion cigarettes as criminal networks consolidated control over tobacco distribution.
British American Tobacco described the 2020 ban as a “critical breaking point” that handed South Africa’s tobacco market to organised crime. The company warns that new restrictions could repeat this pattern, with criminals ignoring regulations while legitimate businesses bear the compliance burden.
Plain packaging has gained momentum worldwide, with 25 countries and territories implementing such regulations as of 2024, representing a significant increase from just 9 in 2018.
However, legal experts note that South Africa may be uniquely positioned in this debate due to its experience with the explosive growth of illicit tobacco trade during the pandemic. The goal of plain packaging legislation is to eliminate packaging as a marketing tool, enhance the visibility of health warnings, and reduce the likelihood of misleading consumers about tobacco risks, but the enforcement challenges in South Africa’s context present unique complications.
Both SARS and the South African Police Service have expressed concerns about their ability to enforce plain packaging regulations effectively. The standardised appearance could complicate efforts to identify counterfeit products during inspections, trace illegal cigarettes through supply chains, and distinguish legitimate from criminal operators.
With three-quarters of the market already operating illegally, authorities worry that plain packaging could provide additional cover for criminal enterprises while imposing new burdens on the minority of businesses operating legally.
The final version of the bill is expected to emerge from parliament in the coming months, potentially reshaping South Africa’s tobacco landscape for better or worse.
ALSO READ: Two arrested and illegal cigarettes worth more than R1 million confiscated
