The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) has set aside an arbitration agreement between Roads Agency Limpopo SOC Ltd (RAL) and civil engineering contractor Axton Matrix Construction CC, ruling that all legal claims stemming from a defective R108,5 million road construction project must be consolidated into a single high court trial.
The unanimous judgment was authored by Acting Judge of Appeal A. C. Basson, sitting with Deputy President D. Zondi; Judges of Appeal R. Schippers and P. Coppin; and Acting Judge of Appeal M. Mabesele.
The appellate panel terminated the contractual arbitration holding that proceeding with parallel arbitration without the design engineer present created an unacceptable risk of conflicting judicial findings.
Heavy rains expose structural failures, blame game ensues
The legal battle stems from a 2013-’14 provincial infrastructure project to upgrade Road D3537 in the Waterberg District from gravel to tar. RAL appointed Matla Consultants CC as professional consulting engineers for R13 million to handle geometric and structural designs and supervise construction. Axton Matrix Construction CC was awarded the main construction contract, valued at approximately R108,5 million.
Work commenced in May 2014, but heavy rains in December 2016 exposed severe structural failures. An independent investigation by BVI Consulting Engineers revealed that sections of the newly constructed road were incorrectly vertically aligned, causing portions of the road to sit lower than the surrounding terrain and act as drainage channels rather than an elevated roadway.
BVI estimated the remedial repair costs at R64,9 million. A blame game ensued: Axton attributed the defects to Matla’s flawed engineering designs, while Matla maintained that Axton’s poor workmanship caused the failure.
Legal action takes swift complicated turn
In August 2018, RAL launched a high court action against both Matla and Axton for R64,9 million in damages. Rather than filing a counterclaim in that action, Axton initiated separate contractual adjudication before adjudicator Bryan Westcott and subsequent arbitration to claim R5,25 million in unpaid retention monies.
RAL objected to the parallel arbitration, stressing that Matla, the design engineer centrally implicated in the dispute, was not a party to the construction contract and could not be compelled to join the arbitration. Fearing duplicated legal costs and contradictory findings across separate forums, RAL applied to set aside the arbitration agreement.
The judicial history in the lower courts involved several judgements. Judge President E. M. Makgoba previously dismissed Axton’s Rule 33(4) application to separate special pleas in the main action. Acting Judge M. S. Lithole heard RAL’s Section 3(2) application in the High Court and dismissed it, finding that parallel proceedings did not establish sufficient “good cause”.
ALSO READ: Appeal court slams Road Accident Fund over evasion of court order
Judge T. V. Tshidada, Acting Judge A. Bresler, and Acting Judge S. Deane, sitting as a full court in Polokwane, subsequently dismissed RAL’s appeal and upheld judge Lithole’s order.
Granting RAL special leave to appeal while refusing Axton’s counter-application, acting judge Basson (with Zondi, Schippers, Coppin and Mabesele concurring) held that RAL had successfully demonstrated “good cause” under Section 3(2) of the Arbitration Act.
The SCA panel ruled that the lower court erred in failing to assess the cumulative effect of the circumstances. The court highlighted that over R108 million in public funds had already been spent on a severely defective road. Because Matla could only be sued in the high court, permitting arbitration to proceed in Matla’s absence created a grave danger that an arbitrator and a high court judge might reach conflicting factual and legal conclusions on identical issues.
Consequently, the SCA set aside the orders of the Full and ordered that clause 10.7 of the construction contract cease to have effect regarding the Road D3537 dispute.
All interrelated claims between RAL, Axton, and Matla will now be resolved in a single high court trial.





