Do coalitions represent everyone?
Can coalitions possibly represent everyone? Photo: Supplied

OPINION: Do coalitions really represent everyone?


Elections – Democracy is built on the idea that every vote matters.

What happens when votes are divided among so many political parties that no single party can govern alone?

Do coalitions offer a more inclusive alternative, one that brings different voices to the table? Or, do they simply create another political arrangement in which the interests of parties take precedence over those of the people?

South Africa’s November 2026 local-government elections have once again brought this question into focus.

Across the country voters have distributed their support among different political parties, leaving a signficant number of municipal councils without an outright majority.

In the Overberg three of the four local municipalities – Theewaterskloof (TWK), Cape Agulhas (CAM) and Swellendam – have hung councils. Overstrand Muncipality (OM) remains under a Democratic Alliance (DA) majority.

On paper, this could be seen as a positive development for democracy.

Rather than place their confidence in one political party votes have given different parties an opportunity to represent their interests.

In theory, coalitions allow different political voices to come together, negotiate and find common ground.

There is something encouraging about that prospect.

No political party should assume that it has all the answers, nor should electoral success give it the impression that it has a monopoly on what is best for a community.

Cooperation, compromise and accountability are essential to a functioning democracy. Coalitions have the potential to encourage all three.

But representation and governance are two different things.

A party can secure a relatively small share of the vote and still become an influential player in coalition negotiations.

  • A good example of this is TWK. Although the DA emerged as the largest party with 39.6% of the vote and 11 seats, it fell short of the 14 needed for an outright majority. The Patriotic Alliance (PA), which received 13.4% of the vote and secured four seats, could therefore become an important player in determining who governs the municipality. Its influence at the negotiating table could extend beyond the proportion of the electorate it represents.

ALSO READ: Elections: And the coalition stays in Theewaterskloof Municipality

Therefore, influence is not necessarily a problem. In fact, it can give voters who might otherwise feel overlooke a voice in local government.

However, the question is what those parties intend to do with that influence.

Are they negotiating to advance the interests of the communities they represent? Or are they negotiating fo positions, portfolios and political leverage?

It is a distinction that matters because people who ultimately bear the consequences of political instability are not necessarily the politicians sitting around the negotiating table.

For young people, this conversation carries particular weight.

We are a generation that has grown up with the promises of democracy.

Yet, many of us continue to confront unemployment, inequality, limited economic opportunities and communities struggling with basic service delivery.

We do not necessarily care which party occupies the mayor’s office if the municipality is failing to create an environment in which we can build our futures.

Coalitions could offer an opportunity to change that.

They could bring together different ideas, experiences and political priorities to develop solutions that a single party might overlook.

But that potential means very little if coalition agreements become exercises in political survival rather than commitments to meaningful governance.

There is also the question of whether young people are genuinely represented in these arrangements.

Having multiple political parties in a council does not automatically mean that different generations, communities and socioeconomic groups have a meaningful say in decisions.

Political diversity is not necessarily inclusive democracy.

As young people, we need more than political parties claiming to speak on their behalf.

We need opportunities to participate in decision-making, influence policies and hold elected representatives accountable.

There is also the question of wheteher young people are genuinely represented in these arrangements.

  • According to an analysis of the Electoral Commission of South Africa’s (IEC) certified candidate list, only 18,71% of ward councillor candidates in the 2026 local government elections were under the age of 35. Of the 98 181 candidates who contested ward positions nationally, just 18 366 fell into this age group.

Thus, young people need to see their concerns reflected in municipal budgets, development plans and the priorities of those governing.

Equally, young people cannot afford to disengage.

It is easy to become cynical when political negotiations appear to revolve around power struggles, leaderhip changes and party interests.

But withdrawing from political conversations only makes it easier for those in power to operate without scrutiny.

Attending public meetings, questioning councillors and participating in local government processes are just as important as casting a vote every five years.

Perhaps the biggest misconception about coalitions is that bringing more political parties into government automatically means more people are represented.

The technicalities of it all

A coalition can command a majority of council seats without necessarily addressing the interests of everyone who lives in that municipality.

Those who voted for opposition parties do not stop being residents, taxpayers or members of the community simply because their preferred party is not part of the governing arrangement.

Ultimately, coalitions should not be judged by how many parties manage to share power, how many positions are distributed or how long an arrangement survives.

They should be judged by whether they can govern effectively, remain accountable and improve the lives of the people they are elected to serve.

For a generation that cannot afford another five years of political stagnation the question is not whether one party or five parties govern.

It is whether those entrusted with power understand that governing is a responsibility to the people, not a reward for political success.

Coalitions may well offer an alternative.

But the real test is whether they offer an alternative that represents everyone.

ALSO READ: Knowing how the Overberg works after the local elections

NovaNews WhatsApp channel QR code

You need to be Logged In to leave a comment.

Gift this article